By Marc Gilman
Questions?
Call (800) 927-9326 or email
Key Takeaways
-
Economists who study “happiness research” have found a consistent pattern: retirees with a traditional pension report being happier than retirees relying solely on savings they’ve accumulated in a 401(k) or similar account. The apparent reason isn’t the dollar amount — it’s the certainty. Seniors like the sense of security that comes with guaranteed, predictable income.
-
If you don’t have a pension, the research suggests a workaround: buy yourself one. Allocating part of a retirement nest egg to an immediate fixed annuity that pays lifetime income can replicate the same guaranteed-income effect a traditional pension provides.
-
A more rigorous look suggests Social Security should usually come first. Stanford Center on Longevity research found that delaying Social Security to age 70 — effectively the best inflation-adjusted “annuity” available to most people — can provide 60–86% of total retirement income for middle-income retirees, which can reduce or remove the need to buy a commercial annuity at all.
-
Annuities still have a real role — especially for the later, harder-to-predict years. A Qualified Longevity Annuity Contract (QLAC), funded from an IRA or 401(k) up to $210,000 in 2026, can start paying guaranteed income as late as age 85 and is excluded from RMD calculations — a targeted way to insure against outliving your money without annuitizing everything up front.
-
That doesn’t mean annuitizing everything. Because most fixed annuity payments don’t rise with inflation, the research points toward annuitizing only part of a portfolio — keeping another portion invested in stocks for growth that can help keep pace with rising costs over a long retirement.
-
Money matters less than you’d think, and relative wealth matters more. Extra savings boost happiness less than people expect; what matters more is the gap between what you have and what you believe you ought to have — and how your lifestyle compares with your neighbors’.
-
Planning ahead measurably helps. Retirees who planned their transition report higher satisfaction than those pushed into retirement suddenly by poor health or a layoff — a reminder that getting the income and cash-flow plan sorted out before you need it, not after, is part of what makes the difference.
-
The softer stuff matters just as much as the financial plan. Staying engaged with part-time work, retiring around the same time as a spouse, and investing in friendships all showed up as real, researched contributors to a happier retirement — alongside the financial security piece.
Where Does This Research Come From?
This isn’t a marketing claim — it’s a summary of findings from economists working in what’s sometimes called “happiness research,” reported by Jonathan Clements in The Wall Street Journal. The piece draws on work from several academic economists, including David Blanchflower at Dartmouth, Keith Bender at the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee, Andrew Oswald at England’s Warwick University, and Erzo Luttmer at Harvard’s Kennedy School. Their research consistently points to a handful of practical levers that correlate with a happier retirement — several financial, several not.
The Pension Finding: Why Guaranteed Income Changes Things
The finding most relevant to retirement income planning is straightforward: Professor Bender’s research found that retirees who receive traditional company pensions report being happier than retirees who have to live entirely off savings accumulated in a 401(k) or similar account. It’s not simply a matter of having more money — it’s that guaranteed, predictable income reduces a kind of background uncertainty that savings alone don’t fully resolve, however large the account balance.
For the shrinking share of workers who still have access to a traditional pension, that security comes built in. For everyone else, the research suggests a direct workaround: an immediate fixed annuity that converts part of a nest egg into a stream of guaranteed lifetime income functions, from a happiness standpoint, much like a pension does. It’s effectively buying yourself the same certainty that pensioned retirees report benefiting from.
A couple of caveats are worth taking seriously, though. An immediate annuity’s income stream generally stops at death unless you’ve paid for a guarantee that extends it — so this is a decision best made in decent health, with a clear understanding of the tradeoff. And because most fixed annuity payments don’t rise over time, the research doesn’t point toward annuitizing an entire portfolio — keeping a portion invested in stocks gives you a better shot at keeping pace with inflation over what could be a multi-decade retirement.
Beyond Income: The Other Findings Worth Knowing
Age and happiness follow a U-shape. Across dozens of countries, happiness tends to decline through people’s 20s and 30s, bottom out in their 40s, and rebound from there — meaning retirement, barring serious illness, tends to be a genuinely happier period of life than the years right before it. One theory: midlife is when people have the least control over their daily schedule, and retirement hands much of that control back.
Planning ahead measurably helps. Retirees who planned their transition into retirement report higher satisfaction than those pushed out suddenly by poor health or a layoff. If an abrupt retirement isn’t avoidable, there’s still real value in thinking through the income plan and the day-to-day picture of retirement life well before you actually need to.
Expectations matter more than account balances. Additional wealth does increase happiness, but by less than most people assume — because so much depends on the gap between what you have and what you believe you’re entitled to, not the absolute number. As one of the researchers put it, “millionaires can feel relatively poor.”
Your neighbors matter too. People judge their financial comfort partly by comparison to those around them. A retiree who moves to a neighborhood they can comfortably afford — rather than one that stretches the budget to keep up — tends to report more contentment than one competing with pricier neighbors.
Working in retirement can help, with a catch. Part-time work in retirement is associated with higher satisfaction, not lower, according to the research. But retirees are less satisfied when they’re not working while their spouse still is — suggesting there’s real value in timing retirement to overlap with a spouse’s, when that’s possible.
Friendships may matter more than possessions. One researcher’s summary was blunt: regularly seeing good friends does more for mental health than a nice car parked in the driveway. The research-backed advice was to invest more in relationships than in material purchases.
A More Rigorous Look: Do You Actually Need to Buy an Annuity?
The Clements piece is a readable, 2005 summary of happiness research — but it’s worth pairing with more technical work on how to actually build guaranteed income, because the more rigorous answer is a bit more nuanced than “buy an annuity.”
A widely cited Stanford Center on Longevity paper, “How to Pensionize Any IRA or 401(k),” tested 292 different retirement income strategies and landed on a surprisingly simple winner for many retirees: delay Social Security to age 70, then draw from savings using the IRS’s Required Minimum Distribution (RMD) formula. Because Social Security is itself an inflation-adjusted, guaranteed-for-life income stream — effectively the best “annuity” available to most people — delaying it to maximize the monthly benefit can do much of the pensionizing work on its own. In the paper’s analysis, Social Security ends up providing 60–86% of total retirement income for middle-income retirees who follow this approach, which can reduce or even eliminate the need to purchase a commercial annuity at all. The tradeoff is a “bridge” period: retirees need other savings to live on between retirement and age 70 while Social Security is paused and growing.
That doesn’t make annuities irrelevant — it reframes them as one tool among several, best suited to filling a specific gap rather than serving as the default first move. One version built for exactly that purpose is the Qualified Longevity Annuity Contract (QLAC): a deferred income annuity funded directly from an IRA or 401(k), which lets you start guaranteed income as late as age 85. As of 2026, up to $210,000 can be funded into a QLAC over your lifetime, and — notably — that amount is excluded from Required Minimum Distribution calculations once you turn 73, which can also modestly reduce taxable RMDs in the years before the QLAC starts paying. As an illustration: a $210,000 QLAC deferred to age 80 might generate roughly $40,440 a year for life — over $600,000 in total payments for someone who lives to 95 (rates vary daily, and actual payments depend on the terms purchased).
Put together, the more complete version of “buy yourself a pension” looks like a short checklist: maximize Social Security by delaying it if your situation allows, use savings strategically to bridge the gap while you wait, and consider a longevity-focused tool like a QLAC or immediate annuity to cover the later, harder-to-predict years of retirement — rather than annuitizing broadly on day one.
What Does This Mean for Your Planning?
The throughline connecting the financial findings is that certainty — not just account size — is what seems to drive retirement satisfaction. That’s a useful lens for evaluating your own retirement income plan: beyond simply checking whether the numbers add up, it’s worth asking how much of your retirement income is genuinely guaranteed versus dependent on markets, withdrawal rates, and how long your savings need to last.
For some retirees, that means taking a closer look at whether a pension-style income stream — through an annuity, properly sized alongside the rest of the portfolio — belongs in the plan, not just as a math exercise, but because the research suggests it may directly improve how retirement actually feels day to day.
What To Do Next
If you’d like to talk through how guaranteed income might fit into your broader retirement plan — alongside your savings, Social Security, and any pension you may already have — we’re happy to walk through the options.
Questions? Call (800) 927-9326 or email
Prefer we reach out to you instead? Complete our Permission to Contact form and a licensed Gilman Agency agent will follow up.
Sources: Jonathan Clements, “The Secret to a Happier Retirement: Friends, Neighbors and a Fixed Annuity,” The Wall Street Journal, July 27, 2005, citing research from David Blanchflower (Dartmouth College), Keith Bender (University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee), Andrew Oswald (Warwick University), and Erzo F.P. Luttmer (Harvard Kennedy School); Stanford Center on Longevity, “How to Pensionize Any IRA or 401(k)”; Fidelity, “QLAC: Qualified Longevity Annuity Contract.”
This article is for general educational purposes and is not a recommendation to purchase any specific insurance or investment product. Annuities vary by issuing company, are subject to the claims-paying ability of the issuer, and involve costs, surrender periods, and limitations that should be reviewed carefully. This is not tax, investment, or legal advice. Consult a licensed insurance professional and a financial or tax advisor regarding your specific retirement planning needs.
