By Marc Gilman
Questions? Call (800) 927-9326 or email
Key Takeaways
-
The question that actually matters isn’t your age, income, or life stage — it’s whether your sudden absence would create financial hardship for someone else. If yes, you likely have a genuine need. If no, you may not.
-
Retirees with sufficient assets and no one relying on their ongoing income often don’t have a life insurance need at all, even though it’s easy to assume coverage is something everyone should carry indefinitely.
-
Dependency isn’t only financial. A spouse who doesn’t earn an income but manages the household or cares for children still provides something with real replacement cost — losing that person creates expenses too, not just lost income.
-
“Want” and “need” are two different conversations. Peace of mind, legacy goals, or estate planning are legitimate reasons to carry coverage even without a strict financial need — but it’s worth knowing which conversation you’re actually having.
-
Once you’ve established that you have a need, the next question is how much coverage actually makes sense — that’s a separate calculation, covered in a companion piece.
The one question that actually matters
It’s easy to think about life insurance in terms of life stage — you get married, you have kids, you buy a house, you get a policy. That’s a reasonable shorthand, but it skips the actual question underneath all of it: if you passed away unexpectedly, would that create a financial hardship for someone who currently depends on your continued support?
As a well-respected financial planner Andrew Rosen, CFP, puts it, the test comes down to this: is someone relying on your continued financial support — either your income or the assets you’d otherwise keep contributing to? If the answer is yes, you likely have a real insurance need. If no one depends on your income or assets, the case for coverage looks very different.
When you probably don’t need it
The clearest example is a retired couple who’ve built up sufficient savings to support themselves without either person’s continued income. If one spouse passed away in that scenario, the survivor isn’t relying on a life insurance payout to fill a gap — the assets built over a working lifetime are already doing that job. In a case like that, life insurance may genuinely be unnecessary, at least as a financial-hardship question.
The same logic applies more broadly any time no one depends on your income or labor: no dependents, no shared debt, sufficient personal assets. That’s a smaller group of people than you might expect, but it’s a real one, and it’s worth recognizing rather than assuming coverage is always the default answer.
Don’t forget the non-earning spouse
One detail that’s easy to miss: needing life insurance isn’t only about replacing a paycheck. A spouse who doesn’t work outside the home, or who earns significantly less than their partner, still provides something that would cost real money to replace — childcare, household management, and everything else that keeps a family running day to day. If that person passed away, the surviving spouse would likely face new costs (childcare, help around the house) on top of the emotional loss. That’s a genuine financial need, even without a salary attached to it, and it’s a scenario people sometimes overlook when they assume only the higher earner “needs” coverage.
Want vs. need: two different conversations
None of this is to say coverage only makes sense when there’s a strict financial hardship to prevent. Plenty of people carry life insurance for reasons beyond a calculated need — leaving a specific inheritance, supporting a cause they care about, or simply the peace of mind that comes with having it in place regardless of the numbers. That’s a legitimate reason to buy coverage. It’s just a different conversation than the hardship-prevention question above, and it’s worth being clear with yourself (and whoever you’re working with) about which one you’re actually having, since it changes what “enough coverage” looks like.
What To Do Next
If you’re trying to figure out whether you have a genuine life insurance need — or whether the coverage you already have still makes sense for your situation — reach out and we’ll talk through it together.
Questions? Call (800) 927-9326 or email
This article is for general educational purposes and is not a recommendation to purchase any specific insurance product, nor tax or financial advice. Consult a licensed advisor to review your specific situation.
